
State Farm® Insurance Agent Darla Pettaway
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Maria SeaStar
March 14, 2025
"I got five star service from Micah. Ask for her. She is the best customer service rep."
"Thank you for the kind words, Maria. We are so glad our team was able to assist you. Thank you for choosing our agency."
Mahiri Moody
March 14, 2025
"A Step up! Just walking through the doors you can feel the professionalism and after meeting the owner, I know why! Great team and a pleasure to work with."
"Mahiri, Thank you so much for the glowing recommendation. We loved assisting you with your insurance needs and look forward to serving you in the future. Thank you for your patronage. "
Bethany Augenstin
March 12, 2025
"I can’t recommend Micah enough! From start to finish, she made the process of getting life insurance incredibly smooth and stress-free. She took the time to understand my needs, answered all my questions with patience and clarity, and found me a fantastic policy that gives me real peace of mind. Her professionalism, knowledge, and genuine care for her clients set her apart. If you’re looking for someone who truly has your best interests at heart, Micah is the person to call!"
"Bethany, I'm so glad to hear about your wonderful experience and the excellent customer service that Micah provided. Thank you for allowing us the opportunity to help you with your auto and life insurance, we look forward to continuing to serve you!"
Demius Frazier
March 7, 2025
"Very nice and understanding. Definitely broke it down to me so I could understand the quotes and rates on insurance better. I’m will definitely refer her to some of my friends and family members."
"Demius, thank you very much for your glowing recommendation. I'm so glad we were able to help you find auto insurance with a great rate. We appreciate your business and look forward to continuing to serve you. "
Kevin Jones
March 7, 2025
"The staff was amazing and very helpful. They have been absolutely amazing and very understanding throughout my membership with State Farm Insurance."
"Kevin, thank you very much for your glowing review. We strive to provide excellent customer service and look forward to serving you in the future. "
C Whitaker
March 7, 2025
"I will have to say this was the best experience I've had with any insurance company. I highly recommend Darla Pettaway."
"I'm so pleased to hear that you had such a wonderful experience. I'm also glad we could help you with your auto insurance! Thank you so much for your business!"
Brandon Arevalo
March 7, 2025
"Jordan always takes care of any services need."
"Jordan prides herself in providing excellent customer service and I'm so glad that she has taken such great care of you in assisting with your insurance needs. Thank you so much for choosing us and we look forward to serving you in the future. "
Kevin Perry
March 7, 2025
"Amazing staff always goes above and beyond to make sure we have what we need!!! Very easy to work with!!!"
"Kevin, We appreciate the kind words and are so glad you were satisfied with your customer experience. It was a pleasure assisting you and we look forward to serving you in the future! "
Michael Cedrone
March 7, 2025
"Great place to get your insurance. Prices are fair. Service is excellent. Switched from progressive and received better rates and service. My agent Jordan made the process easy and smooth. She took the time to answer all my questions and answered question I asked. I would recommend them to anyone."
"Michael, Thank you so much for your patronage, we appreciate your business. Jordan prides herself in providing excellent customer service. I'm so glad we could help you with your auto insurance and the rates exceeded your expectations. We look forward to continuing to serve you! "
Nichole Emmons
March 7, 2025
"Jordan S was able to get me and my son a life insurance policy and save us $450 a year on our auto insurance. I definitely recommend Darla’s agency to anyone looking for insurance!"
"I'm so glad Jordan provided you with such wonderful customer service and was able to assist you with auto and life insurance! We appreciate your patronage!"
James Chauncey
March 7, 2025
"I am the husband of Laura, and also the person who suggested she switch to State Farm. I read your response today and feel compelled to set the record straight with truth. Let's be clear. She was not reviewing the prior agency, it was yours. You claim that she was always responded to within 24 hours, yet the emails prove that this is not true. You further state that you didn't know she was unhappy, and yet she sent you and Navaeh an email on 3/3/25 stating not to let her policy renew. Navaeh's response on 3/4/25, which you were copied on said "Noted thank you!" Please let us now when you get your proof of new insurance...So, for you to say you didn't know is the second untrue statement."
"James, thank you for your words and patronage. I reviewed the email history thoroughly and with the exception of one email where the person the email was sent to was out sick, she was responded to within 24 hours each time from this office (if there is anything beyond that, I cannot find proof of it in the records and would welcome sending me a copy so I that I can address it appropriately as that is unacceptable in accordance with our office policy). Often when customers choose to not renew their policy it is because they found a more favorable rate, not because they are unhappy with some aspect of their service so that is not something I would typically assume. I will take note that it would be appropriate to request further explanation when requesting a cancellation or renewal and once again I apologize for the frustration, that is certainly never our intent; we want each customer to feel valued (because they are) and appreciate the feedback. "
Chelsea Robertson
March 7, 2025
"Like a good neighbor, Lacey is ALWAYS there! Top-tier customer service, always willing to help where needed, professional at finding the best rates as she pulled some absolutely impeccable ones for me and the communication between the office and myself is just outstanding!! Truly have never met another soul who cares so deeply about her job and customers until I stumbled across Lacey! She takes pride in everything she does and I couldn’t be more grateful! I’m saving over $1000 a year on insurance and now have started a life insurance policy that doesn’t break the bank either! 10/10 recommend⭐️"
"Chelsea, I am so glad that Lacey has provided you with such excellent customer service! We appreciate you choosing us as your insurance agency! "
ariana morales
March 7, 2025
"Lacey is always super helpful whenever I have a question or I have to update my policy."
"Ariana, I am so glad that Lacey has provided you with such wonderful customer service. She prides herself in the service she provides. We look forward to continuing to serve you. "
Mrs A
March 7, 2025
"I had an incredible experience with Darla’s office and agents. They were extremely professional, knowledgeable, and timely. Although insurance isn’t super fun they made the experience enjoyable and stress free. I highly recommend if you haven’t switched now is the time!"
"We are so pleased that you had such a wonderful experience! We look forward to serving you in the future! "
Laura Bentley
March 6, 2025
"My husband and his family are lifelong State Farm fans, staying loyal to the same Tampa-based agent for years. When he encouraged me to try State Farm, I decided to go with this local agency instead. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to my expectations. While payments were processed without major issues (aside from receiving unnecessary threatening notices despite being on auto-pay), the real disappointment came down to professionalism and customer service. I never felt truly valued as a customer when I had questions or concerns—kindness and responsiveness seemed to be in short supply. The good news? I found a new provider that not only offers better service but also saves me about $600 a year. I hope this agency takes the opportunity to improve, as professionalism and customer care make all the difference in building lasting customer relationships."
"Laura, I'm sorry to hear about your experience as we definitely value each customer and strive to provide excellent customer care. You've actually been with another agent for most of your tenure with State Farm and we only recently inherited your policy. Our office policy is to respond to each customer query and find resolution within 24 hours and from all records it appears we have done so in your case. I wish I would have been made aware of your concerns or needs to properly address them. "
Diego Gil Edo
January 28, 2025
"I was very lucky to get Jordan Sawmiller assigned to me to give me a quote. Best customer service I've got from an auto insurance company so far!!"
"Diego, Jordan prides herself in providing great customer service and I'm so glad that you had such a great experience. We look forward to continuing to serve you and appreciate your business. "
suzanne whitworth
January 18, 2025
"Darla and her Team are intentional and caring! Give them a call today!"
"Suzanne, thank you so much for your kind words, we love our customers and pride ourselves in giving them the best service possible!"
Yalina Meneses Yanes
January 7, 2025
"Keely… she is the girl you are looking for. she is fast and competent and will Give u good options, I’d like her!! And also highly recommend"
"Yalina, thank you so much for your kind words and glowing recommendation. I'm so glad Keely was able to provide you with good options and provide excellent customer service. Thank you for allowing us to serve you! "
Kerry-Ann Rahate
November 25, 2024
"Keely is the absolute best. Thank you for your prompt response to all my inquiries. You are truly the best."
"Kerry-Ann We're thrilled to hear that Keely has been so responsive and helpful. She truly is amazing, and we’re lucky to have her on our team. We'll be sure to share your appreciation with her! We look forward to serving you in the future!"
Mike Bates
November 25, 2024
"Keely has been amazing for us. As young professionals, we initially found it challenging to comprehend the intricacies of various insurance policies. However, all of the associates have consistently demonstrated patience and expertise in answering our questions and providing clear explanations. Their exceptional service has instilled confidence in us and eliminated any consideration of switching to another insurance provider. The comprehensive support and value they offer extend beyond the policies themselves, making them an invaluable asset to our insurance needs."
"Mike, thank you very much for the words and recommendation. We appreciate your business and look forward to continuing to serve you. "
William Shaw
October 16, 2024
"I had auto insurance with Darla Pettaway's agency, and needed a home owner's policy due to a property purchase. I shopped for quotes and State Farm was overall the best. However, the communication from Jordan S was amazing - during a few weeks with 2 hurricanes. Jordan's average response time was in minutes; not hours or days like the mortgage lender and HOA. When I had a firm closing date, Jordan supplied needed documents immediately. The overall purchase experience was extremely stressful, but Jordan's exceptional service made it much better! Highly recommend!"
"William, thank you so much for the kind words! I'm so glad that Jordan eased the stress of the home buying process and gave you such wonderful service! We look forward to continuing to serve you in the future! "
Mila Began
September 18, 2024
"The best in Sarasota! Very friendly, punctual and best prices we got in Fl."
"Mila, thank you so much for the kind words. I am so glad we were able to find you the right auto insurance for your needs and provide you with great customer service. Thank you for allowing us to serve you."
Nick Decos
September 13, 2024
"Been getting ripped off for years… saved a lot by shopping out my policy I suggest you do the same"
"Nick, our office didn't write your policy but took it over from another agency. Our office doesn't determine your rates, that is a corporate underwriting but we provide you with customer service and service your policy. We apologize you weren't happy with your rates but as I said before, that isn't something our office controls. "
Rick Mintzell
August 20, 2024
"Darla is a sweetheart! Very nice person!"
"Rick, thank you so much for the kind words and review. It is such a pleasure serving you! Darla"
Mike LaValliere
May 28, 2024
"Simply brutal handling of my policy! Changed insurance companies the first week of April this year because State Farm increased my premiums significantly without reason. They still charged my account. I’m yet to be reimbursed as of 5/27. “Corporate” problems I was told. Don’t autopay with them."
"Mike, I apologize for the issues you are having with your refund. Your monthly payment was due and processed 5 days prior to your cancellation request. It was not processed after your cancellation. We unfortunately do not directly process refunds, that is processed by corporate. I apologize that there was a technical error, but rest assured you will be provided the refund for the days that you had other coverage. We submitted everything in a timely manner as you requested and cannot control system and bank errors. "